Reflection: What Are We Afraid of Losing?
15th November 2026
By Rev Dr Fei Taule’ale’ausumai
Judges 4:1–7 | Matthew 25:14–30
Talofa lava and greetings to those who have joined us online.
This morning, Matthew presents us with another challenging parable. This time, it is about money, responsibility, risk and fear.
And alongside it, we encounter Deborah, one of the most remarkable women in the Hebrew scriptures.
At first glance, these two readings appear to have very little in common. One tells the story of a woman who exercises leadership during a time of national crisis. The other tells of three servants entrusted with enormous amounts of money.
Yet both invite us to consider a question that touches every one of our lives:
What are we afraid of losing?
Is it our security? Our reputation? Our position? Our financial independence? Our relationships? Or perhaps the familiar ways of doing things that have given us a sense of belonging and control?
And what happens when our fear of losing something becomes greater than our willingness to act?
Deborah: The courage to challenge power
The book of Judges introduces Deborah during a particularly difficult period in Israel’s history.
The Israelites have been suffering under the oppressive rule of King Jabin of Canaan. His military commander, Sisera, possesses nine hundred iron chariots, a formidable military advantage in the ancient world.
For twenty years, the people have endured oppression.
And into this situation steps Deborah.
She is introduced as a prophet, a judge and a woman who exercises considerable authority. People come to her for guidance and judgement.
Deborah does not wait for someone to give her permission to lead. She recognises the suffering of her people, understands the circumstances confronting them, and summons Barak to take action.
What interests me about Deborah is not simply that she is a woman exercising leadership in a patriarchal society, although that in itself is significant.
It is that her leadership emerges from a willingness to confront injustice.
She does not accept oppression as inevitable.
She does not say that the situation is too complicated, that the enemy is too powerful, or that nothing can be done.
She recognises that something must change.
Deborah reminds us that courage is not necessarily about being fearless.
It is about recognising when fear must no longer determine our actions.
And that raises a question for us today.
How often do we remain silent because speaking might cost us something?
How often do institutions protect their reputations rather than acknowledge injustice?
How often do churches avoid difficult conversations because we are afraid of upsetting people, losing members or threatening financial security?
Sometimes the greatest obstacle to change is not the absence of resources.
It is the fear of what change might cost us.
The parable of the bags of gold
Now we turn to Matthew.
Jesus tells a story about a wealthy man who, before leaving on a journey, entrusts his property to three servants.
One receives five talents, another two, and the third receives one.
We need to remember that a talent in the ancient world was not a personal ability, as we commonly understand the word today.
It was an enormous unit of money, worth many years of a labourer’s wages.
Even the servant who receives only one talent is entrusted with extraordinary wealth.
The first two servants put the money to work and double what they have received.
But the third servant takes his talent, digs a hole in the ground and buries it.
When the master returns, the first two servants are praised and rewarded.
The third servant is condemned.
That is when we look more closely, the parable becomes rather uncomfortable.
The third servant explains his actions by saying that he knows his master is a harsh man, someone who reaps where he has not sown and gathers where he has not scattered seed.
In the world of first-century Palestine, wealth was concentrated in the hands of relatively few people. Its still the same in the world today.
Landowners and powerful elites often accumulated wealth through systems that placed enormous burdens upon ordinary people.
Debt, taxation and the loss of ancestral land were realities familiar to Jesus’ listeners.
Within that context, the master’s expectation that his money should multiply raises some difficult questions.
Who benefits from this accumulation? Who bears the cost? And what happens to those who refuse to participate?
Some biblical scholars have suggested that the third servant might be understood not simply as a coward, but as someone who refuses to cooperate with an exploitative system.
That is not the only possible interpretation, and the parable does not resolve the question neatly.
But it is worth exploring.
Perhaps the third servant is afraid because he knows the consequences of displeasing someone who holds power over him.
Perhaps burying the money is the only form of resistance available to him.
Or perhaps his fear genuinely prevents him from exercising responsibility.
Either way, we are confronted with the relationship between fear and power.
Fear can make people compliant.
Fear can silence those who know that something is wrong.
Fear can prevent people from questioning systems that benefit some while disadvantaging others.
And sometimes those who appear to be doing nothing are actually struggling to survive within circumstances they did not create.
We need to be careful, therefore, about judging the third servant too quickly.
I suspect that most of us can identify with all three servants at different stages of our lives.
There are times when we have taken risks, made difficult decisions and discovered possibilities we never imagined.
There are also times when we have chosen security over uncertainty.
And there may have been moments when fear has prevented us from acting at all.
But fear is not always irrational.
Sometimes we have very good reasons to be afraid.
People fear losing their jobs because they need to feed their families.
People fear speaking out because they have experienced the consequences of challenging authority.
People fear change because they have already lost so much.
And people fear becoming vulnerable because they have learned, sometimes painfully, that not everyone can be trusted.
Have we become so determined to protect what we possess that we have forgotten what it means to live generously?
Have we become so concerned about preserving institutions that we have lost sight of the people those institutions were created to serve?
And have we confused faithfulness with maintaining the status quo?
This is where Deborah’s story offers us another perspective.
Deborah does not act alone.
She calls upon Barak, and the wider narrative reminds us that change requires the participation of others.
Her leadership is exercised within a community facing a common struggle.
That matters.
Because too often we celebrate individual courage while overlooking the responsibility of communities to create conditions in which people can act without fear.
We tell people to speak up, but do we listen when they do?
We encourage people to take risks, but do we support them when things go wrong?
We celebrate leadership, but are we willing to share power?
And in our churches, do we genuinely welcome different voices, or only those voices that affirm what we already believe?
Deborah challenges us to think about leadership not as the protection of privilege, but as responsibility for the wellbeing of others.
Her courage is directed towards liberation.
And perhaps that is where these two readings begin to meet.
The real question may not be how much we have been given, or how successfully we have multiplied it.
The deeper question is what we are doing with the power, opportunities and resources available to us.
Are they being used to protect ourselves?
Or are they contributing to the flourishing of others?
Here at St Andrew’s on The Terrace, we speak often about justice, inclusion, compassion and the importance of creating a community where everyone belongs.
These are not simply attractive words to place in a mission statement.
They are commitments that sometimes require courage.
They may require us to challenge accepted practices, question inherited assumptions, and acknowledge when the church itself has contributed to exclusion or harm.
And sometimes they require us to recognise that the gifts we have been entrusted with are not ours to keep for ourselves.
Our buildings, our financial resources, our knowledge, our relationships and our influence all carry responsibilities.
But so too do the less visible gifts. The gift of listening. The gift of hospitality. The gift of speaking truth when silence would be easier. The gift of knowing when to step aside so that someone else may lead. And even the gift of recognising our own limitations.
As we draw towards the end of another church year, perhaps these readings invite us to reflect on what we have been holding too tightly.
What assumptions might we need to release? What fears have prevented us from embracing change? What injustices have we become so accustomed to that we no longer recognise them?
And what possibilities might emerge if we were willing to trust one another more deeply?
Deborah reminds us that even entrenched systems of power can be challenged.
The parable of the talents reminds us that money, responsibility and fear are never as straightforward as they first appear.
And Jesus invites us to imagine a realm of God that is not built upon accumulation, intimidation or the punishment of those who fail to produce.
Rather, throughout his ministry, Jesus points towards a different understanding of abundance.
An abundance measured not by profit, but by relationships.
Not by possession, but by generosity.
Not by domination, but by justice.
Not by fear, but by love.
Perhaps the greatest thing we are afraid of losing is control.
Control over our circumstances, our institutions, our resources and even our future.
Yet life continually reminds us that control is never absolute.
What remains within our power is how we respond to one another.
Whether we choose compassion over indifference.
Whether we choose courage over silence.
Whether we choose to protect privilege or share responsibility.
And whether we are willing to imagine something different.
So perhaps the question for us this morning is not simply, “What are we afraid of losing?”
Perhaps it is also:
What might we gain if we were no longer governed by fear?
We might discover new courage.
We might find unexpected companions.
We might create space for voices that have too long been silenced.
And we might discover that what truly enriches our lives is not what we manage to hold on to, but what we are willing to share.
May we have the wisdom of Deborah to recognise when change is needed, the courage to question the powers that diminish life, and the generosity to use what we have for the wellbeing of all.
For perhaps the greatest risk is not losing what we possess. Perhaps the greatest risk is becoming so afraid of losing it that we forget how to live. Amen.
Audio of selected readings and reflections
Audio of the complete service
THANK YOU